Colgate vs Smith
How Colgate and Smith stack up on the numbers that decide where you apply: selectivity, cost after aid, testing, and essays.
| Colgate | Smith | |
|---|---|---|
| Acceptance rate | 20% | 21% |
| SAT (middle 50%) | 1460-1530 | 1420-1540 |
| Testing policy | Test-optional | Test-optional |
| Type | Private | Private |
| Location | NY | MA |
| Sticker price (per year) | $87,070 | $82,890 |
| Average cost after aid | $29,055 | $31,200 |
| Supplemental essays | 3 | 1 |
- Colgate is harder to get into than Smith (20% versus 21%), so treat it as the bigger reach.
- After aid, Colgate is usually the cheaper option ($29,055 versus $31,200 per year on average).
- Both are test-optional, so you can apply without submitting SAT or ACT scores.
- Colgate asks for more supplemental writing (3 essays versus 1), so budget more time for its application.
- Run the free chances calculator to see your real odds at both, then get a free read on each school's essays.
Colgate vs Smith FAQ
Is Colgate or Smith harder to get into?
Colgate is harder to get into, admitting about 20% of applicants versus 21% at Smith.
Is Colgate or Smith cheaper?
After financial aid, Colgate is usually cheaper, about $29,055 per year on average versus $31,200 at Smith.
See your real chances at Colgate and Smith.
Build my college list